The Raleigh Contact Lens Institute

Menu
Menu

Call / Text:

(919) 850 5910

GP Lenses vs Scleral Lenses – A Comparison

Choosing the right specialty contact lens can significantly impact comfort, vision clarity, and long-term eye health. For patients with irregular corneas, keratoconus, or contact lens intolerance, two common options are gas permeable (GP) lenses and scleral lenses.

 

While both are designed to improve vision beyond what glasses or soft lenses can offer, they function very differently.

  • What Are GP Lenses?

GP lenses are small, rigid lenses that sit directly on the cornea. They allow oxygen to pass through the lens material, providing sharper vision than soft contacts for many complex prescriptions.

 

These lenses are often prescribed for mild to moderate corneal irregularities and offer excellent optical quality. However, because they move with each blink, some patients experience initial discomfort or lens awareness.

  • What Are Scleral Lenses?

Scleral lenses are larger lenses that rest on the white part of the eye (the sclera) and vault completely over the cornea. A fluid reservoir fills the space between the lens and the cornea, creating a smooth optical surface.

 

This design not only improves vision but also provides constant hydration and protection for sensitive or damaged corneas.

  • Comfort and Stability Comparison

One of the most noticeable differences patients experience when comparing gp lenses vs scleral lenses is comfort. GP lenses can feel noticeable due to their smaller size and movement, especially during the adaptation period.

 

Scleral lenses, by contrast, tend to feel more stable and comfortable because they do not move with each blink and maintain a consistent position throughout the day.

  • Vision Quality and Performance

Both lens types offer superior visual clarity compared to standard soft lenses. GP lenses are effective for correcting irregular astigmatism, but scleral lenses often provide more consistent vision by neutralizing a wider range of corneal surface irregularities.

 

Patients with higher levels of distortion or post-surgical irregularities often experience better outcomes with scleral designs.

  • Which Patients Benefit Most From Each Option?

GP lenses may be suitable for patients who:

 

  • Have mild corneal irregularities
  • Do not experience significant dryness
  • Can tolerate lens movement

 

Scleral lenses are often recommended for patients who:

 

  • Have keratoconus or advanced corneal disease
  • Experience severe dry eye or lens intolerance
  • Have post-surgical corneal irregularities
  • Final Thoughts

Both GP and scleral lenses play an important role in specialty contact lens care. The best option depends on corneal shape, comfort needs, visual goals, and lifestyle factors.

 

A detailed evaluation using advanced imaging technology is essential to determine which lens design will deliver the best long-term results.

  • Frequently Asked Questions
Which is more comfortable: GP lenses or scleral lenses?
Scleral lenses are generally more comfortable for most patients because they rest on the sclera and do not move with each blink. GP lenses are smaller and may cause more initial lens awareness.
Both lenses provide excellent vision, but scleral lenses often offer more consistent clarity for patients with advanced corneal irregularities or post-surgical distortion.
GP lenses typically involve a simpler care routine. Scleral lenses require filling with sterile saline and more detailed handling, but many patients adapt quickly.
GP lenses may be a good option for patients with mild irregular astigmatism, good tear quality, and who tolerate lens movement well.
Yes. Scleral lenses maintain a fluid reservoir over the cornea, which helps protect the eye and improve comfort in patients with moderate to severe dry eye.
Yes. Both GP and scleral lenses require advanced measurements and professional fitting to ensure proper vision, comfort, and eye health.
Tagged , , ,